Aubrey Lance, S. S. - Season 1
It turned out the tri-fold poster really was perfect for our crime-board. It had plenty of space to hold our limited information, plus I’d be able to fold it and tuck it away somewhere when we weren’t using it.
I snapped a photo of the page from Emery’s notebook with my phone, then sent it to my printer, and we taped it right in the center of the board. Around it went notes about my dreams—the ones of Emery at the water, which were mostly the same dream again and again, aside from her sometimes quoting Poe and sometimes not; and the two dreams I’d had about Chloe—the one at ProScoop with her talking to Devin and a hawk flying around her, and the one of the lizard-thing stealing her wallet from her backpack—along with a quickly jotted note about my suspicion that the few pages that had been torn out of Emery’s notebook might have had relevant information we were missing.
We also added a printed picture of Chloe and one of Emery, hand-sketched drawings of ProScoop and the beach where Emery had last been seen, and a list of the theories the cheerleader-hawks had given us: That Chloe may have been taken because she resembled Emery. That Chloe may have been taken as a way of targeting me. That Emery might still be alive.
Just taping that one to the board sent a tremor through my chest.
We connected the relevant theories to each of the photos with taped-on strands of blue yarn from my old arts-and-crafts bin.
Collin stepped back, evaluating our work. “You’re right, it’s not much to go on, but I like the yarn. It feels official.”
I studied the board. “We missed something.” I grabbed a piece of paper and scribbled out another theory, then tacked it to the board with a strand leading to Emery—not an accident. I turned to Collin. “If any of what the cheerleaders had said was true, Chloe’s disappearance was either connected to Emery’s, or they were both connected to me, but either way, that means even if Emery did drown, if she isn’t still alive—then she didn’t just drown. It was part of something bigger. It couldn’t have been an accident. Right?”
I desperately hoped Emery was still alive, but even the cheerleaders hadn’t been willing to commit to that theory. Part of me leaned into the possibility that she’d been forced into the water that night, that there might be a reason for her death even if it meant she really was gone, while the other part wanted to run away screaming.
Collin’s eyes landed on mine. “Maybe. Or maybe these cheerleaders don’t know what they’re talking about.”
I thought for a second. “They knew about the gossamer web quote, though, Collin. And my dreams. And Emery’s notebook page. It doesn’t make sense for them to guess all that.”
He nodded. “Okay… but I saw three cheerleaders turn into hawks and fly away today, Aubrey. I’m not exactly banking on what makes sense right now.”
I stared at him. “How are you taking all of this so well?” I felt like I was on the brink of completely losing my mind, and he was just… Collin.
He shrugged. “I watched a lot of Buffy with my mom when I was younger.”
I waited for the smirk, but he was serious.
A laugh escaped me. “You are a strange duck, Collin.” Somehow, he’d lifted my mood again, even in the middle of all this.
Now the smirk came. “I prefer the term lone wolf, but I’ll take it,” he said, then turned back toward the trifold. “We can’t show this to pretty much anyone, Aubrey. You realize that, right? Your parents will think you’ve gone nuts, and outside of them and Lockley, we don’t know who else we can trust.”
He wasn’t wrong about my parents—I’d already come to that same conclusion. I couldn’t show them any of this until I had incontrovertible proof that it was real. Plus, if there was a chance Emery was alive out there somewhere, and my parents did somehow believe me… I couldn’t get their hopes up, only to crush them again.
I looked at Collin. “Are you suggesting we should tell Lockley?”
He shook his head. “Not unless we have to. She’s not exactly a vault of secrets.”
But as I looked back over our trifold of scanty info, I realized suddenly, she was.
Lockley was exactly a vault of one very specific type of secrets: Emery’s.
“Ohhh.” The word seeped out as the realization hit me. “I need to talk to Lockley. Now.”
Collin glanced back at me. “That’ll be kind of difficult, since she’s on a field trip today.”
Right. I sighed. “I guess we have some time to kill, then.” That crawling-out-of-my-skin feeling was coming back. I hoped I could make it through the wait without losing my mind.
Collin turned to face me. “You haven’t touched the nachos, but how do you feel about hot chocolate? I make it homemade.”
I looked at him, surprised. “That sounds great.”
Collin texted Lockley to ask her to come to my house when she got home from the field trip, then he got permission from my parents to use the kitchen, and left briefly to go home and get his homemade hot chocolate ingredients.
As soon as Collin left, I folded up our trifold and tucked it under my bed.
Just in time, too, because my mom poked her head in. “You okay?”
I sighed. “Yeah. It’s just… a lot.”
My mom came in and sat down on my bed. “I know it is, honey. Is there anything I can do?”
She didn’t know the half of it, but I still appreciated her compassion.
I sat down by her and gave her a hug. “I just want to find Chloe.” And I desperately wanted to find Emery, too, if she was still out there—but I couldn’t say that.
Mom pulled me tight. “I know. I promise, when I hear something from Mary, I’ll let you know. I won’t keep you in the dark.”
It could be bad news, when news came. We both knew that too well. But knowing my parents wouldn’t hide it from me gave me a measure of peace. Hard or not, I wanted the truth.
I hugged my mom tighter. “Thanks.”
A few minutes later, Collin returned and started bumping around in the kitchen downstairs.
Mom leaned away to look at me. “You know, I think that boy likes you.”
I jerked back. “What?”
“He’s making you homemade hot chocolate, Aubrey. You think this is something he does for his guy friends at school?”
I didn’t think Collin had any guy friends at school—or any friends at all, yet—but that was beside the point.
“He’s Lockley’s brother,” I said. “He’s just being nice.”
Mom gave me a knowing smile. “If you say so. But remember to keep this door open, in case you think about kissing him. Your dad and I can hear you talking, you know. If it goes quiet, we’ll be checking.”
I stared at her. “Ew, Mom.”
Then my heart skipped a beat. “Wait, do you mean you were listening to our whole conversation?”
She smoothed my hair. “We can’t hear words from down there, just the murmur—whatever you needed to get off your chest, we wanted you to have space. We’re glad you have a friend here for you.” She eyed me. “But I’ll be listening for that silence.”
I gaped at her. “Again—ew.”
She laughed. “I’m going to go make sure he’s not destroying my kitchen.”
She headed downstairs.
By the time Collin returned to my room with two steaming cups of hot chocolate, my mom’s comment had gotten to my head. Although I knew she was dead wrong about Collin’s interest in me, I couldn’t help analyzing every little thing about our interactions, even the way Collin looked at me as he handed me my mug.
“Careful, it’s still kinda hot,” he said.
His eyes lingered on mine—but that didn’t mean anything. People look at people. I was overthinking.
“Thanks,” I said, quickly taking the hot mug. I crossed the room and set the mug on my desk, then reconsidered and took a tentative sip not to seem rude. My mouth exploded with heat—it really was hot—but then the flavor hit me through the pain. “This is good,” I said, looking up at him in surprise.
“I added some secret ingredients. There’s nothing scary in there, though, unless you care about calories.” He smiled. Those dimples again. “You don’t seem like someone who cares about calories.” He stopped. “Not that I’m insinuating you’re—I mean—I didn’t mean that like it sounded. I just meant—” He was beet-red by the time he stopped trying to fix his sentence. “Nevermind.”
I could’ve taken his bumbling statement as an insult, but he looked appropriately mortified, and honestly, I didn’t usually pay much attention to calories because I only ate sweets here and there, and I was fine with how I looked even if it wasn’t catwalk-worthy.
“You really do make good hot chocolate,” I said instead as I set my mug back down, and he relaxed. I sort of wished I’d pretended to be offended. It would’ve been amusing to watch him squirm.
He gave me a tentative smile. “Thanks.” He set his mug down on the desk near mine. “Want to pull the trifold back out?”
I considered it, but I didn’t know when my parents might come back to check in… which also meant we had to be careful about conversation.
I looked up at him. “Actually, do you mind if we take our hot chocolates to the backyard?”
***
The next episode is coming right up! Check my blog for the official posting schedule.
Want to reread a previous episode? Click here to be taken to the main Season 1 forum menu, where you can see all available episodes!